Geeks2U Promise
We guarantee you'll love our fast, friendly service - or we'll refund your money.  
133,572 Happy Customers & Counting
Need tech support?
1300 769 448
Extended hours, 7 days a week
Home  /  geekspeak  /  Australia’s piracy crackdown will just drive pirates underground

Australia’s piracy crackdown will just drive pirates underground

Roger

New laws to block piracy websites won’t stop people stealing movies, it will just make pirates much harder to catch.

Australia’s piracy crackdown has stepped up a notch, with new copyright laws set to force internet service providers like Telstra and Optus to block websites such as The Pirate Bay. Rather than addressing the cause of piracy by confronting rights holders and demanding they stop treating Australians as second class citizens, the government finds it easier to bow to the demands of copyright lobbyists and introduce online roadblocks which will be child’s play to bypass.

We can at least be thankful that the piracy crackdown will be an open and transparent process. Australian businesses can go to court and demand that a website be blocked if the site is “facilitating access to” its content, or content that it has licensed for Australia. This broad definition lets them target websites like The Pirate Bay which don’t actually host content, but instead act as the middleman to allow people to share content via BitTorrent.

In order for a site to be blocked, the complainant must convince a judge that the “primary purpose” of the site is to facilitate copyright infringement. This process should make it harder for copyright holders to take a shotgun approach to blocking sites, assuming judges don’t simply rubber stamp every application. It will certainly provide greater safeguards against abuse than the previous government’s proposed pornography filter, which would have seen bureaucrats making such decisions behind closed doors.

Australians attempting to visit blocked piracy sites will be told that the site is blocked and why, unlike the pornography filter which was to remain wrapped in secrecy.

Despite these checks and balances, the law still feels like it is weighted heavily in favour of copyright lobbyists rather than consumers. The government shot down a proposed amendment to allow third parties like consumer advocacy groups to come to the defense of websites they feel are unjustly targeted – which doesn’t exactly instill confidence that the government wants a fair and balanced copyright system.

For all the fuss about the new website-blocking laws, they will do very little to stop Australians accessing these websites. Many Australians already use a Virtual Private Network to mask their location so they can beat geo-blocking and bluff their way into foreign streaming video services such as US Netflix, Hulu and BBC iPlayer. Switching on a VPN will just as easily let Australians bypass any website filtering efforts put into place by their ISP.

VPN features are built into practically every computer, smartphone and tablet – once they’re set up you can enable them with a single click – but Australians might not even need to go to this much trouble. The legislation leaves the method for blocking websites up to the judge and the ISP, which means they’ll likely take the easy option of changing the listing for The Pirate Bay on their DNS servers.

Think of DNS servers as internet telephone directories which convert website names into strings of numbers known as IP addresses. When you try to visit a website such as google.com.au, your computer checks with your ISP’s DNS server to find the IP address for that domain name – in this case 216.58.220.131.

By listing the wrong IP address for thepiratebay.gd, an ISP can stop its customers reaching the site – just like deliberately listing the wrong number in the telephone book. The problem with this plan is that it’s simple for anyone to change to a different directory, such as Google’s own DNS server which might run faster than your default DNS server. Alternatively they might use a DNS service like UnoTelly, Unblock US or Getflix, which offer an alternative to VPNs for reaching geo-blocked foreign websites.

At this point the government’s piracy roadblocks will vanish, unless ISPs use more complicated and expensive ways to block websites. Even then, a VPN will still do the trick. Considering that many Australians already use VPNs and DNS workaround, they might not even notice the piracy roadblocks. People who do will soon find a way around them, then we’ll be back where we started except the government will have driven pirates underground rather than encouraging them to mend their ways.

FacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Recent News

world

The ambition behind Google’s Street View was (originally) to provide a little more human context to people’s map searches. It’s all very good to say that a journey will take so many minutes, or that you need to make this sequence of turns in order to get to your destination, but it’s long been a… More 

snapdragon

Ever since the computer market shifted from desktop PCs to laptops, there’s been a significant balancing act going on between the needs of computer users for processing power to run programs, and the needs of those same users for battery power to keep their laptops going. At a simplified level, the harder you push a… More 

Apple-Apple

For the longest time, the generally accepted knowledge was that Apple’s Mac computers didn’t get malware or viruses. Apple even went so far as to mock its PC opposition in the famous “Mac vs PC” ads for the issues they had around security and malware, to a fairly solid effect. While Apple’s Macs do still… More 

intel

Quite often these days when we hear about a major security flaw, it’s to do with the underlying software that we’re running on our PCs, whether it’s a dodgy browser exploit, some kind of flaw in productivity software or even “free” content sites that are awash with malware. It’s not quite so often that we… More